Wilbert Coffin was executed on February 10, 1956, after a trial built on circumstantial evidence, suppressed witnesses, and tunnel vision. Bill C-40 — the law created to review miscarriages of justice — received Royal Assent in December 2024. The Commission it promises still does not exist. This site asks, for his family: why is it taking so long?
Three American hunters — Eugene Lindsey, his son Richard, and Frederick Claar — went missing in the Gaspé woods. Wilbert Coffin, a prospector and father, was the last person to see them alive. He even helped search for them. Then he became the only suspect, and the state's case never recovered from that convenience.
The conviction rested entirely on circumstantial evidence. No physical evidence ever linked Wilbert to the murders.
His lawyer called no witnesses; Wilbert never testified. Key witnesses were not called and critical evidence was withheld from the defence.
Alternative suspects were never properly investigated. A criminal defence lawyer and criminology professor identifies the hallmarks of a miscarriage of justice: police tunnel vision, judicial misconduct, ineffective counsel.
With international attention from the United States, the government pushed police for a resolution. Wilbert was a vulnerable, convenient answer.
He maintained his innocence to his final breath. If the evidence was so strong, why was the case so weak?
Seven decades. One family. One unanswered question.
Three American hunters go missing in the Gaspé. Wilbert Coffin, who helped them with their stalled vehicle, is the last person known to see them alive — and joins the search.
The bodies are found. Despite limited, circumstantial evidence, Wilbert is arrested, tried, and convicted of the murder of Richard Lindsey.
Wilbert is hanged at Bordeaux Prison in Montreal. Even his final wish — to marry Marion, James's mother — is denied by the state. A father. A husband. An innocent man, executed.
Journalist Jacques Hébert publishes J'accuse les assassins de Coffin, igniting public doubt.
The Brossard Commission hears hundreds of witnesses — then concludes the trial was fair. Decades later, its materials sit under a ban: the "locked door" blocking the family's fight.
Canada abolishes the death penalty for murder.
Innocence Canada takes up the case and begins the fight for review.
Prof. Kathryn M. Campbell releases The Coffin Affair, a six-episode podcast revisiting the miscarriage of justice.
Bill C-40 — the Miscarriage of Justice Review Commission Act ("David and Joyce Milgaard's Law") — receives Royal Assent. Justice confirms it can review posthumous cases like Wilbert's.
Key provisions come into force; the old ministerial process winds down.
No commissioners appointed. No commission operating. The Justice Department refuses to explain the delay. The family waits.
The counters above keep counting. So do we.
In a fair case, the file is the proof. In this case, the file is locked away.
Some police files concerning Wilbert Coffin have been sealed for 99 years. When CBC asked Quebec's Justice Ministry why, the Ministry did not respond.
The Brossard Commission generated material never heard at trial and interviewed people who never testified. Much of that work was placed under a ban — ████████████ a locked door, in the words of Innocence Canada, ██████████████████ that the family has not been able to open.
Suppressed evidence. Sealed files. Silent ministries. Secrecy is not justice.
If the trial was fair, what are the files afraid of?
The law exists. The promise was made. The building is empty.
Bill C-40 moved review power away from the Minister of Justice to an independent commission of a chief commissioner and 4–8 others, meant to make reviews easier, faster, and fairer.
Royal Assent: December 17, 2024. Provisions in force: March 6, 2025. Today, the Commission remains non-operational, and the Justice Department has refused to grant interviews explaining the delay.
Justice has confirmed the Commission can review posthumous cases like Wilbert's. Every day of delay is another day an innocent man's name stays stained.
What is taking the Commission so long to form? Why, seventy years on, is it taking so long to clear Wilbert Coffin's name?
Canada has done this before. We know how the story ends when the review mechanism sleeps: the innocent wait decades.
Condemned at 14. The old ministerial review turned him away; it took 48 years, collapsed forensic evidence, and undisclosed proof before an acquittal. The review mechanism failed him once — it is failing Wilbert now.
Twenty-three years lost to tunnel vision and flawed forensics. Bill C-40 is named "David and Joyce Milgaard's Law" — yet the commission bearing his name remains unbuilt.
Convicted twice on erroneous hair-and-fibre forensics and tunnel vision; cleared by DNA. The same forensic overreach echoes in 1954.
Eleven years lost to bias; a royal commission found the system failed him because of who he was. Judicial bias is an old ghost in this country's courtrooms.
Criminal defence lawyer and criminology professor Kathryn M. Campbell spent years in the Gaspé and in the archives. Her six-episode series, The Coffin Affair: A Miscarriage of Justice Revisited, is the audio casefile. Listen at wilbertcoffinaffair.com.
Murder in the Gaspé
Police Investigation & Arrest
Politics & Place
The Trial
The Death Penalty
The Making of The Coffin Affair
Seeing the injustice is not enough. Choose your part in ending it.
Demand Wilbert's case be reviewed as priority the day the Commission opens — and demand commissioners be appointed now.
Family Petition Appoint CommissionersInnocence Canada has carried Wilbert's fight for over a decade. Fund the experts and lawyers who keep the locked door from staying shut.
Donate to Innocence Canada